Did Dumbledore Want Snape To Have The Elder Wand
Dumbledore had hoped Snape would gain control of the Elder Wand when he killed him but he didnt understand that it wouldnt rightfully go to Snape because they had agreed on this matter and the wand wasnt taken against his will. This essay will unpack why Dumbledore kept the knowledge of Harry being a Horcrux from him and whether or not Dumbledore told Snape about the Elder Wand.
Who Told Voldemort Where The Elder Wand Was Quora
By asking Snape to kill him by planning this Dumbledore intended that he - as the Wands owner - would not be defeated so the Elder Wand should have lost its power.
Did dumbledore want snape to have the elder wand. In the last book Ollivander the Wand-maker tells Harry that any wands allegiance must be won. Additionally Dumbledore trusted Snape to keep watch on Hogwarts after the deed was done. Before Snapes death Voldemort gives him a talk about all the wands he went through and when he tells Snape that the third wand he sought was the elder wand and he took it from Dumbledores grave Snape reacts with shock and his face looks white and like a death mask.
Harry with The Elder Wand. If the plan had worked the Elder Wands magic would have died with Dumbledore and even if Voldemort killed Snape to get the Elder Wand which he did he still wouldnt have gotten it. Dumbledores planned murder wasnt really to do with the Elder Wand.
Professor Snape killed Dumbledore at the astronomy tower but the wand did not belong to him because Draco Malfoy had disarmed him earlier. Ultimately it was to strengthen Voldemorts faith in Snape. - So Snape could remain in Voldemorts company and wherever possible protect Harry without Harry knowing.
Unbeknownst to Snape Dumbledore had also done this to ensure that when Snape killed him Dumbledore would not unintentionally be defeated as they had agreed to it beforehand and Dumbledore intended to pass on the Elder Wand to Snape and was ready to accept death and thus the mastery of the Elder Wand would be. The preceding unsigned comment was added by 178190152219 talk contribs. Apart from the previous owners that were either killed or disarmed professor Snape was also killed by Lord Voldermort though Snape was not the true owner of the wand.
That could work but if Dumbledore really did want to end the power of the Elder Wand which seems iffy at this point this would mean he wanted Snape and then Harry to own Wand but not master it. Because Malfoy hadnt actually taken Dumbledores life the power wasnt transferred so Malfoy and therefore Voldermort didnt actually have access to the full power of the Elder Wand. But the Elder Wands true owner was Draco because he was the one who attacked the wands owner Dumbledore last so when Harry disarms Draco and gets his wand which isnt the Elder Wand he is actually the Elder Wands true owner.
My interpretation of this phrasing is that although Dumbledore knew that for his long game he did not want Snape to have the Elder Wand the compassionate part of him did. The Elder Wand which he stole from Dumbledores tomb wont work for him because he isnt the true master of it. It was a very good plan and he would have gotten away with it had it not been for that meddling Malfoy and those pesky Death Eaters.
The first essay published yesterday was about whether Dumbledore intended Snape to have the Elder Wand and whether he wanted Harry to hunt for the Deathly Hallows. As Dumbledore stated in Tales of Beedle the Bard Those who are knowledgeable about wandlore will agree that wands do indeed absorb the expertise of those who use them With the. The truth was in asking Snape to kill him Dumbledore was sentencing Snape to death.
Even when he killed Snape he did so thinking that the murder would grant him control of the Elder Wand and not because he learned about Snape being a spy for Dumbledore. Well the Elder Wand was in Snapes possesion after Dumbledore died bc Dumbledore intended Snape to be the owner. The Wands power would be broken in terms of the line of mastery so this is not the advantage of giving to Harry.
Remember Dumbledores entire plan was for Voldemort to kill himself with the Elder Wand after he took it from a minion. Instead Snape killed Dumbledore but still gave the wand to Malfoy to give to Voldermort. I suspect it was a trap.
Similar to the obliviousness of Voldemort some hardcore fans of the series were perplexed to learn that there even exists a Snape and Dumbledore ship. Snape killed Dumbledore for two reasons. The Elder Wand was repeatedly seized by power-hungry wizards as Xenophilius tells Harry The bloody trail of the Elder Wand is splattered across the.
Nobody would be so stupid as to let something so powerful just lying around well except Harry. - Because Dumbledore would have died anyway. Draco was unaware that he was the true owner of the Elder Wand at that moment and never wielded it.
Draco Malfoy might not have been the one who killed Albus Dumbledore as Severus Snape intervened but he did become the rightful owner of the Elder Wand after disarming the powerful wizard. Because Snape killed Dumbledore Voldemort believes the wand will obey Snape so. In the twentieth century the wizards Gregorovitch Gellert Grindelwald and Severus Snape were all slaughtered in Lord Voldemorts pursuit of the Elder Wand.
Why Didn T Poisoning Dumbledore Win Voldemort The Elder Wand Considering How Much Weaker Albus Became Quora
How Did Albus Dumbledore Get The Elder Wand Quora
Why Didn T Dumbledore Just Destroy The Elder Wand Quora
Why Did Dumbledore Choose To Keep The Elder Wand With Him In His Grave Quora
Harry Potter Fans Freak Out Over Dark Theory About Dumbledore Jk Rowling Agrees
Why Didn T The Elder Wand Work For Voldemort Quora
Pottermore The Elder Wand Harry Potter Sanati Harry Potter Sanat
Pin By Cindysiyu On Harry Potter Harry Potter World Accio Harry Potter Hp Harry Potter
If The Elder Wand Was With Dumblebore In His Tomb How Did Harry Potter Win It From Draco Malfoy Quora
Did Dumbledore Never Actually Gain The Elder Wand S Allegiance If Grindelwald Stole The Death Stick And Never Had Its Loyalty To Lose Quora
Did Snape Know That Draco Is The Master Of The Elder Wand Quora
Why Does Dumbledore Say He Was Permitted To Use The Elder Wand Quora
How Many People Recognized That Dumbledore Owned The Elder Wand Science Fiction Fantasy Stack Exchange
Why Does The Elder Wand Belong To Draco Quora
Same Albus Dumbledore Literally Had The Best Fashion Sense Harry Potter Jokes Harry Potter Memes Harry Potter Universal
Why Did Dumbledore Want The Elder Wand To Be Passed On To Snape Originally Quora
If We Exclude The Elder Wand From The Conversation Is Snape A Duelist On Par With Dumbledore And Voldemort Quora
What Was Dumbledore S Plan For The Elder Wand Why Didn T He Bequeath It To Someone Harry Or Snape For Safekeeping Quora